Dance Gavin Dance is one of those rare phenomena where intentional chaos and randomness can turn out to be good, albeit divisive. They're understandably not a band for everyone, and with what Punk Rock MBA called the "widdly-widdly gene", it feels like they should be some sort of a impossibility, with all signs pointing to "this shouldn't be so good but it is". Regardless, I love it to death and beyond, and the fanbase generally agrees, this being regularly stated as their best album to date. It's hard to disagree, considering the level of refinement and style achieved in this masterpiece of an album.
The Tilian era has undoubtedly been the impression that I got of Dance Gavin Dance, considering my first taste of the band was with Instant Gratification, and as much as I love that album, after listening to both an equally insane amount of times, I have to admit that Mothership triumphs as their best work. The guitarwork continues to impress with this unique style that's all over the place yet catchy that I've come to know as the affectionately named swancore genre. The drums control the intensity of the songs so precisely throughout the album, anything from throwing on a laidback pop punk groove for a flowier part or laying down some insane metal-esque double kicks for the heavier sections. Admittedly I've never paid much attention to bass (not like I do anywhere) but when it shines, it shines very bright (like Count Bassy in Artificial Selection).
The dual vocalist dynamic has never been more impressive than with Tilian and Jon Mess. What would be a generic lineup and performing style with a clean and unclean vocalist is so creatively transformed into a pseudo-instrument of its own, comfortably using vocals to enhance the rhythm and melodies. While most bands write well with only having one vocalist sing at a time, Dance Gavin Dance masterfully peppers in sections of overlaps, call and response type beats, or even use one vocalist as a background element while the other goes all out. Not to mention, both vocalists on their own are absolute gods of their style, Tilian's vocal range and cleans are angelic and Jon's screams are so uniquely gritty and consistent, neither need to go to the extremes of their range to sound great but sound amazing when they do.
We can definitely credit Jon Mess for the band's seemingly random lyrics most of the time, but you gotta admit it's fun and enjoyable. Even then, their songs don't all mean nothing, and tracks like Inspire The Liars tell such meaningful stories its shocking that they sit next to tracks like Petting Zoo Justice. My all time favourite from the band has to be Man Of The Year, I just feel that this is where they peaked in every aspect that makes Dance Gavin Dance, Dance Gavin Dance. The rest of the tracks still hold their own, even the lesser known tracks have enough bite to leave an impression for a long while.
Rating: 10/10