I loved Divinely Uninspired To A Hellish Extent, it is one of my top few pop albums of all time, so I think you can guess my excitement for a new Lewis Capaldi album after four years of waiting. I'll be honest, the singles were not promising, especially with Pointless, but after the album came out I've had the time to sit with it and listen to it a few dozen times, and I'm very happy to say that it was far from disappointing.
As the four singles released one by one, I got more worried about the general production value of the record. There was a noticeable tiktok-ification of the song's writing and structure, and the production was vastly different from his debut. Pointless was completely unlikeable, and the rest were bearable at best, but it felt like there was an element of authenticity missing from the few tracks. Between a seemingly overproduced vocal mix and a weird choice of instrumentation that felt too generic pop, it felt like the unique sound that blew him up in the first place was missing from this album cycle.
My hopes were slightly restored when the full album released. I found some of the songs quite enjoyable to listen to, and a majority of the record is listenable. I definitely have gripes, but it is an overall good-leaning mixed bag. His strongest suit still remains with choruses, and there are a handful of songs that are hard-carried solely by the chorus, while the verses on just about all the songs fail to impress me. There's a certain lack of confessionality and vulnerability in the writing that Divinely Uninspired To A Hellish Extent had, which I felt was a big part of the appeal, which leaves this record a bit bare and uninviting. It also suffers from sounding very generic and familiar to the trend of tiktok songs, being written with little to no thought on the bigger picture and instead going off of little moments that are engineered for virality and easy listening. There's a subtle lack of genuine emotiveness, and the vocals sound a bit hollow. The dynamics also seem a bit off, and the lack of any cut that feels Headspace-esque or even Fade-like is a bit sad. It lacked a lot of the essence that made Divinely Uninspired To A Hellish Extent such a good listening experience, one that you can sink into while feeling all the emotions, but Broken By Desire To Be Heavenly Sent just feels so, pop.
There are things to like about the record, despite all my gripes. The venture into stronger pop instrumentals has a few strong hits, like the slightly synth-pop upbeat Heavenly Kind Of State Of Mind, which is one of the most cohesive tracks on the record, or the keyboard heavy Leave Me Slowly which even features a guitar solo that left me pleasantly surprised. His choruses have gotten stronger, with the likes of Burning, How This Ends and Haven't You Ever Been In Love Before? being some of the strongest choruses around. I think it was commendable that he wanted to expand his sonic territory and experiment a bit, even if the results were not the most impressive.
Do I think it's a sophomore slump? No, not at all. Does it beat Divinely Uninspired To A Hellish Extent? Absolutely not. Despite it's slight messiness and different sound from its predecessor, I think it was a formidable output of music from Lewis Capaldi. I don't see myself loving it as much as I did the first record, but it has done nothing to dull my love for his music. I've chosen to view this record as a bit of a transitional, experimental or intermission-like record, one that has as much of talent as before, but simply run through a different machine and came out different. Whether this was exactly what he wanted to have made for his second record, I won't know, but like I mentioned before, it wasn't disappointing so I have not much to hate about it.
Rating: 8/10